I also got eggs, sausage and toast. Again – the sausage – not as good as Bluebird. It was fine but nothing to get too excited about.
Larry went for his traditional “first time in a diner” meal and got a steak hoagie. He also thought it was fine but nothing special.
Why Should You Go? It’s pretty standard diner fare – and the staff is very friendly. It’s ALWAYS busy – so I think the neighborhood loves it. There’s another diner down the street that is always empty – so I think if you’re in Mt. Healthy – you go to Brotherton’s. It very much has that small-town feel – which we liked. I’m sure there is something there that will be my favorite – I just have to find it.